Instead of thinking about CNAPP as the evolution of CSPM + ASPM, the reality is that security programs still require best-of-breed solutions in each category because:
✔
CSPM is focused on cloud misconfigurations and compliance.
✔
ASPM is focused on pre-runtime security execution and vulnerability prioritization in software development.
✔
CWPP,
RASP, and
EDR each tackle their own specialized aspects of runtime protection.
Most CNAPP solutions did not start as a unified platform—they are the result of multiple acquisitions, each originally designed for separate security functions. Take Palo Alto Networks, for example:
Similarly, Wiz, the CSPM leader, acquired Dazz to enter the ASPM market, further proving that CNAPPs are trying to bolt on ASPM as an afterthought rather than engineering security culture from the core—at every single product team level.
Key Question: Is CNAPP a deliberate security strategy, or just a rebranded collection of stitched-together tools designed to check all the boxes?
1️⃣ CNAPP Doesn’t Solve Pre-Production Security
2️⃣ CNAPP Doesn’t Prioritize Developer Adoption
3️⃣ CNAPP Isn’t Purpose-Built for Software Teams
Instead of relying on CNAPP “platforms” that attempt to be everything but specialize in nothing, companies should adopt a best-of-breed strategy that aligns ASPM and CSPM as complementary, specialized solutions.
Approach | Pros | Cons |
---|---|---|
Best-of-Breed ASPM (Start Left) & CSPM | 🔹 Purpose-built for core problems 🔹 Fully integrated into DevSecOps 🔹 Flexibility in security tool choices | 🔹 Requires integration work 🔹 May need multiple vendors |
CNAPP (All-in-One “Stitched” Platform) | 🔹 Single vendor relationship 🔹 Marketing-friendly “unified” solution | 🔹 Features often bolted on, not built in 🔹 Lack of depth in key security areas 🔹 Can create false sense of security |
The Reality: Security teams don’t need more checkboxes—they need solutions that actually solve security problems at the core instead of masking symptoms.
ASPM vs. CSPM vs. CNAPP vs. Runtime Tools
Category | What It Does | Primary Focus | Key Users | Start Left's Role |
---|---|---|---|---|
ASPM (Application Security Posture Management) | Tracks, prioritizes, and enforces security within software development | Pre-runtime vulnerability management, developer adoption, security execution | AppSec, Engineering, DevOps | Foundation for pre-production security & risk reduction |
CSPM (Cloud Security Posture Management) | Identifies misconfigurations and compliance issues in cloud environments | Cloud security misconfigurations, compliance | Cloud Security, IT, Compliance | Contextualizes cloud security risks to product teams |
CNAPP (Cloud-Native Application Protection Platform) | Bundles CSPM, CWPP, and some ASPM-like capabilities | Cloud security enforcement, runtime protection | Security Teams, IT, DevOps | Not a true ASPM replacement—complements CSPM but lacks developer engagement |
CWPP (Cloud Workload Protection Platform) | Protects running workloads from runtime threats | Runtime security for workloads | Cloud Security, SOC Teams | Focused on cloud runtime, doesn’t impact secure development |
RASP (Runtime Application Self-Protection) | Monitors and blocks application threats in real-time | Detects and mitigates application attacks | Security, DevOps, Engineering | Reactive protection—doesn’t prevent vulnerabilities at the source |
EDR/XDR (Endpoint & Extended Detection & Response) | Detects and responds to security incidents across endpoints & workloads | Threat detection & response | SOC, IT Security Teams | Focused on incident response, not proactive vulnerability management |
💡 If ASPM isn’t in place, CNAPP & CSPM are just cleaning up problems that should have been fixed in development.
Why Start Left Champions Best-of-Breed Security
The Bottom Line: ASPM and CSPM Need to Work Together—Not Get Forced Into a Single Platform
Organizations should be skeptical of the “one-size-fits-all” CNAPP pitch. Instead, security leaders should prioritize:
Are You Building Security at the Core—Or Patching It Together?
If your security strategy relies on bolt-on acquisitions and marketing buzzwords instead of best-of-breed solutions, it’s time to rethink your approach. Let’s talk about how Start Left can complement your cloud security stack with purpose-built ASPM.
Also see: The Illusion of Integration: How CSPM & ASPM Acqusitions Are Building Silos Within a Platform
The Only ASPM for Speed & Growth—Not Bloat